GS valedictory Class Day speech plagiarized? (UPDATE: Yeah, it definitely was)
Behold, the power of the Internet! This morning, GS valedictorian Brian Corman was accused of lifting part of his Class Day speech from comedian Patton Oswalt’s “Physics for Poets” routine. Oswalt has taken to his Twitter in reaction to online tips.
Video of GS Class Day has been made private on Columbia’s YouTube page, but Corman’s speech is still available via webcast on the Commencement 2010 page. (Download his speech for RealPlayer here and Windows Media player here.) Corman’s speech begins at the 42:27 mark and the anecdote begins at 47:42.
Update, 1:46 p.m.: The University has put the GS Class Day video back on its YouTube channel with an apology (reprinted below) as an annotation to the video.
Update, 3:46 p.m.: Oswalt updated his website after Corman apologized to him, saying that he “flat-out admitted his thievery, his stupidity. Owned it all. Good man.” But the comedian didn’t let him off that easy, writing, “Still makes me wonder what he might have done to become valedictorian—I mean, if he’s willing to steal material for something as inconsequential as a speech, how rubbery did his boundaries become when his GPA and future career were on the line? Oh well.”
Update, 5:00 p.m.: GS Dean Peter Awn’s separate statement, similar to the YouTube annotation:
It has come to our attention that a portion of our Valedictorian’s remarks at this year’s School of General Studies Class Day was taken from a comedy routine by Patton Oswalt. As an institution of higher learning that places a core value on respect for the works of others, we were surprised and disappointed to have learned of this matter today. Columbia University and the School of General Studies do not condone or permit the use of someone else’s work without proper citation. The student speaker has appropriately issued an apology to his classmates and to Mr. Oswalt for failing to provide such attribution.
Peter J. Awn
Columbia University School of General Studies
Not clear whether this means the University has spoken with Corman, or how else (or what else) they know about his apology. Keep checking back for further updates.
Update, 5:40 p.m.: According to the University, the video was taken down temporarily from YouTube (as noted by Oswalt) to post the statement that now appears with it. In addition, the University cannot comment on any potential disciplinary actions facing Corman due to Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act restrictions on the disclosure of personal information. The apology message from Corman to Oswalt, though, was a private correspondence between the two that did not involve the University.
Still no word from Corman himself, but keep checking back.
Videos of Corman’s speech and Oswalt’s set after the jump.
Corman’s speech begins at 34:33 and the portion from Oswalt begins at 38:36:
Transcription of the annotation from the University on the video:
It has come to our attention that a portion of our Valedictorian’s address at this year’s Columbia University School of General Studies Class Day was taken from a comedy routine by Patton Oswalt. Until today we were unaware of this conflict, and as an institution of higher learning that upholds the highest standards of respect for the works of others, we are deeply distressed that this has occurred. Columbia University and the School of General Studies do not condone the use of someone else’s work without proper attribution. Mr. Corman has issued an apology to Patton Oswald [sic]. — School of General Studies, May 25, 2010
Parts one and two of Oswalt’s set:
Leave a Comment
Be nice. Don't use HTML tags. And consider reading our full comment policy.