News | Mar. 13 7:49 pm EST

Student Governing Board issues two statements regarding SJP banner

Tova Kamioner / Spec

Columbia’s Student Governing Board issued two statements on Thursday afternoon in response to the removal of the Students for Justice in Palenstine’s banner advertising Israeli Apartheid Week from Barnard Hall.

In the first statement, signed by every member of the SGB’s executive board except treasurer Tess Glassman-Kaufman, BC ’15, said, “Barnard College’s decision to remove this locale as a platform upon which students and organizations can express themselves, violates administration policy and further endangers the future of free speech on this campus. We, as the Student Governing Board, urge Barnard to reconsider its decision regarding the utilization of this space for all groups on campus.”

In the second statement—a dissent written by Glassman-Kaufman, also the director of campus affairs for LionPac—reads, in part, “Whether intentional or not, this statement alienated a large portion of the student body and as a member of the Student Governing Board, I cannot stand behind this.”

You can read both statements, in full, after the jump.

The mission of the Student Governing Board is to represent and serve the needs of Columbia University student organizations whose concerns are religious, spiritual, political, ideological, activist, humanitarian, or identity-conscious in nature. The SGB is dedicated to the principle of community self-government, and believing that in the final analysis, those students’ needs can best be evoked, defined and articulated by the students themselves. Furthermore, the Executive Board of the Student Governing Board oversees and provides support to its student organizations.

As a Governing Board dedicated to freedom of speech and impartiality, the SGB would like to emphasize every student group’s right to advertise their events and voice their missions on the campuses of all four undergraduate colleges. When these rights are infringed upon, it falls on the Executive Board to support the interests of all its groups and speak out against the injustice.

As a result, SGB would like to issue a statement iterating their disappointment at the decision made by Barnard College President Deborah Spar to remove a banner containing the logo and mission statement of Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP), an SGB recognized student organization, without any dialogue or consultation with SJP. Despite the outstanding policy iterated by President Spar in her response that “It has been a long-standing tradition to allow any recognized Barnard or Columbia student group to reserve a space and hang a banner promoting their event”, this specific banner was taken down without warning or consideration for the group’s event. President Spar further went on to say that “These Barnard Hall banners have always been student-created and, as such, reflect the diversity of student interests and concerns, but are not meant to convey an endorsement.” Thus, it is quite concerning when a banner that represents the concerns of students on campus is removed without any discussion with the group about the content or the reasoning behind the removal. It is alarming that the administration could act so swiftly in silencing any group and have such executive power over the content that students choose to share on this campus. In addition, as a result of the administration’s actions, this group feels marginalized and threatened on this campus. The group has received threats and feels that they cannot even look to the administration for support and protection.

Barnard College’s decision to remove this locale as a platform upon which students and organizations can express themselves, violates administration policy and further endangers the future of free speech on this campus. We, as the Student Governing Board, urge Barnard to reconsider its decision regarding the utilization of this space for all groups on campus. It is important that all groups have the opportunity to advertise their events on all of the four campuses at Columbia University. By taking away this space, the administration will be limiting the reach of many groups that would utilize this space to advertise to the Barnard community. It would be a shame to see that occur and to have the voices of such varied communities silenced. Thus we urge the Barnard administration to reconsider any decision made regarding this space and to include student groups in the conversation. Any policy regarding this space, especially one that will not allow any group to utilize the space, will affect the student body at large and as such the student body should have an active role in discussion. The administration should not limit the reach of student voices, instead it should help support the sharing of different ideas which is absolutely crucial for the diverse community that Barnard values so highly. Without this space, not only would the Columbia community be losing a space for our communities to share ideas and advertise events, but we would be losing the autonomy to share any thoughts and ideas that we deem fit, no matter how unpopular.

In the end, Columbia is a community and as such we cannot allow our voices or the voices of our peers to be quelled. Each and every group should have the right to share their opinions no matter how controversial or unpopular they may be, it is not for the administrations to decide what is an appropriate opinion or point of view, unless said opinion is advocating violence. Columbia University has long been a forum where students can share their voices and ideas freely; the Student Governing Board would hate to see that change with actions like the removal of this banner.

The Student Governing Board calls upon the Barnard Administration to: first, call for the end of the threats that this group has received as a result of this incident by addressing the topic publicly; second, communicate with student groups before making executive decisions such as this one in the future; third, reconsider the removal of the banner; fourth, to continue to allow this space to be used for advertising purposes by all groups on campus, and fifth, to remember that the voicing of opinions, no matter how singular or strong, is the essence of our culture at this institution.

Fatimatou Diallo, Chair

Mariam Elnozahy, Vice Chair

Aishwarya Raja, Secretary

Sameer Mishra, Representative

Ankita Gore, Representative

Karim Nader, Representative

Priyanka Javlekar, Representative

Doreen Mohammed, Representative

David Morales-Miranda, Representative

Maya V Pandit, Representative


While this statement was passed by majority vote of the Student Governing Board, I would like to express more thoroughly, my dissenting opinion.

As the Student Governing Board, it is our duty to stand for the freedom of speech and the well being of the student body on this campus. I feel that we have failed to do so this week in responding to SJP’s banner placed on Barnard Hall.

Every group deserves the right to expressing their opinion on campus and there are numerous outlets to allow students these opportunities. However, placing a politically charged banner on the entrance to Barnard Hall indicates a direct endorsement of a specific political agenda on behalf of the college. Furthermore, the banner threatened the safety of the pro-Israel community on campus by suggesting that Israel has no right to exist as a Jewish State. Whether intentional or not, this statement alienated a large portion of the student body and as a member of the Student Governing Board, I cannot stand behind this.

I fully support SGB’s request of Barnard administration to call for an end to all threats; our primary concern ought to be assuring that this campus is a safe space that does not threaten students. I agree that all opinions, no matter how singular or strong, should have a voice on campus, which is why I feel so strongly about making this statement. I agree that there should more fluid communication between administration and students, and look forward to Barnard making a clearer policy about its advertising space.

I fully support the removal of the banner, and appreciate the Barnard administration taking the safety of its students seriously, and refusing to be implicated in endorsing a hostile message.

 Tess Glassman-Kaufman, Treasurer




  1. why is is relevant that tess is in lionpac? • March 13, 2014 at 8:05 pm • Reply

    you didnt mention the group affiliations of the other members of SGB. lionpac played no role in this incident

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: +7 (from 17 votes)
  2. biased • March 13, 2014 at 8:36 pm • Reply

    what are the other board members involved in outside of SGB?

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: +4 (from 14 votes)
  3. Former SGB Board Member • March 13, 2014 at 11:25 pm • Reply

    Many of the people on the SGB board are connected to activist communities of all kinds- if you’re going to single out Tess as a member of Lionpac, you should be drawing clear lines between the members who signed on to the other statements and the organizations they are involved with. Spec–you know how to report well; please be all that you can be in a situation like this.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: +3 (from 13 votes)
  4. Comments are spot on ^^^ • March 13, 2014 at 11:53 pm • Reply

    Inconsistent to call out Tess on being a member of Lionpac without making note – in any manner – what groups the remaining members are in.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: +2 (from 6 votes)
  5. here's a more specific question • March 14, 2014 at 11:02 am • Reply

    why don’t you report that vice-chair mariam elnozahy is on the C-SJP facebook group?

    she clearly should have recused herself

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: -4 (from 4 votes)
    • Anonymous • March 14, 2014 at 11:12 am • Reply

      She did

      VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
      Rating: +2 (from 2 votes)
      • Anonymous • March 14, 2014 at 3:09 pm •

        how do you know? and yet her name is on the statement…

        VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
        Rating: 0 (from 2 votes)
    • LOLOL • March 16, 2014 at 12:52 am • Reply

      Means NOTHING. President of LionPAC, Aviva Pratzer, is also on the group. why don’t you report that you’re an idiot?

      VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
      Rating: +1 (from 1 vote)
  6. Didier Ortiz • March 15, 2014 at 11:11 pm • Reply

    If you believe speech should be banned based on sensibilities then you don’t really believe in freedom of speech. Glassman-Kaufman, Zionism is a dying ideology. Don’t go down with the ship.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: +2 (from 4 votes)
  7. To be perfectly honest • March 16, 2014 at 12:47 am • Reply

    Singling out either Elnozahy or Glassman-Kaufman doesn’t really matter in the grand scheme of things. These people are all members of SGB, are entitled to their opinions, and were selected for their roles fully aware that they may have personal involvements in work being done. What’s significant is that 10/11 people voted in favour of this statement and Glassman-Kaufman basically called for the extermination of free speech based on “alienating” opinions.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 4 votes)
  8. Anonymous • March 19, 2014 at 8:56 pm • Reply

    An open pond will make the inhabitants victim to outside predators such as bi,cheap beats headphones, cats and wildlife. or sometimes South america, the actual off-white imitation leather reduce and lightweight rare metal computer hardware demonstrate all of us an vigorous handbag. Discountmugs. Tour bus affords any Poppy pouches through this design and style.Yet if you need to apperceive extra,cheap beats sale, when the designate is normally identified rich in type. N. about 25 miles north of N

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
  9. IBeats Pas Cher • March 21, 2014 at 10:25 pm • Reply

    Customizing clerical vestments are among the popular methods of getting their very own unique liturgical product.This takes just a minute,Casque Beats Pro Pas Cher, and good judgment.After the floor is prepped it can be stained a color of selection or left natural this a matter of inclination after staining a clear urethane is applied developing a safety finish for the floor.In creating luxurious and healthy handcrafted shoes,casque beats by dre pas cher,The best way to writ The best way to writ

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)

Leave a Comment

Be nice. Don't use HTML tags. And consider reading our full comment policy.